Live-Metal.Net
 
   
 

BETWEEN THE BURIED AND ME
‘The Great Misdirect’
(Victory)

Review by Ryan Mavity
Buy in Live-Metal.net Shop

Call me a little biased on this one.

I’ve become a huge fan of North Carolina’s Between The Buried And Me (oddly, the name comes from a Counting Crows song) over the past year and a half. For those that have never heard this band before, it is unlikely you will hear anything quite like them. BTBAM is deemed “progressive metal” but their music defies even that easier characterization, as the band mixes pop, prog-rock, death metal and pretty much everything else you can think of.

The band’s earlier releases tended to stay close to their metal roots, albeit with a progressive influence. The band’s 2005 release Alaska began incorporating acoustic elements and 2007’s critically acclaimed Colors used everything but the kitchen sink: acoustics, metal breakdowns, piano-style keyboard playing and, yes, even a country hoedown. BTBAM’s latest release, The Great Misdirect, continues and expands upon the styles incorporated on Colors. And while the ending is not quite as satisfying as it is on Colors, the band continues to unleash some of the most challenging and innovative sounds in metal today.

The Great Misdirect begins with the almost soft, surf-guitar inflected “Mirrors,” a similar opening trick as the band used on Colors’ “Foam Born (a) The Backtrack.” Still, the song shows the band’s gift for melody and that, when they want to, these guys can do pretty melodies better than most pop groups can. “Mirrors” immediately segues into the first single, “Obfuscation,” a track that provides a 9-minute demonstration of what BTBAM can do. Vocalist and keyboardist Tommy Rogers gives a nasty death metal growl over a suffocating metal breakdown from guitarists Paul Waggoner and Dustie Waring. At around the four-minute mark, the band segues in and out of an almost dreamlike section with a dose of thrash, highlighted by a bass/guitar duel between bassist Dan Briggs and Waggoner, before ramping things up again for a boot-stomping big finish.

“Disease, Injury, Madness” is an 11-minute dose of prog-metal in its simplest form, so much so that it should come with Roman numerals or letters attached. The first section is pure death metal. At the two-minute mark, things shift into Pink Floyd mode with a soft guitar-keyboard interlude. The guitars and drums pick up again as the song winds down as Waggoner plays a David Gilmour-inspired blues solo. The horse noises in the background may be a bit much though.

“Fossil Genera – A Feed From Cloud Mountain” starts off with a circus-like introduction before the band joins in and slowly turns the song into a crushing headbanger. The song the evolves into an almost country sounding song, with a mellow acoustic guitar by Waring, a sad guitar solo by Waggoner and a light, but trippy vocal by Rogers. 

This only sets the stage for the 5-minute interlude “Desert Of Song,” which features shared lead vocals by Waggoner and Rogers. The song has an almost campfire vibe to it, especially as Waggoner sings in a countrified croon. There’s an almost Layne/Jerry Alice In Chains dynamic here. It’s one of the most intriguing songs BTBAM has ever done and shows that this is no mere metal band.

As great as the first five songs come off, the band’s only misfire is the nearly 18-minute (yes, 18 minutes) closer ‘Swim To The Moon.” While the song does have some amazing playing from all five band members – a bad ass Celtic guitar call-and-response around the 10-minute mark and a nice acoustic breakdown at the end – it’s the only track where it feels like the band is showing off. It’s as if the band had so many ideas they didn’t quite know how to end the record. While “White Walls” from Colors also lasted 15 minutes, that song seemed to flow better, whereas “Swim To The Moon” seems to go on and on.

Still, that’s a blip on what is otherwise a terrific album. Many critics may point out that BTBAM’s flashy solo work and long song times (half the songs are more than 11 minutes) is excessive and, truth be told, it is. But it’s that excess that helps make this band a unique listening experience in metal. There aren’t many groups out there willing to take these kinds of chances and do it in a way that comes off beautiful and brutal at the same time. While I don’t think it’s quite the masterpiece Colors was, The Great Misdirect is a worthy follow-up.